Nickel's Pit BBQ Watkins Glen Menu (Update 2025)

Simply the world's best chicken wing. Split sauces or rubs by 10s.

House-fried tortilla chips topped with our classic pulled pork, jalapeno peppadew cheese sauce, pico de gallo, dry rub sour cream, jalapenos, and our original hot sauce.

Crispy tots with melted local cheddar, bacon, green onion, dry rub sour cream, and ranch. Like a loaded potato.

Tender, slow-smoked pork shoulder from lowery farms in savona, ny. Served on a fresh baked roll. Unsauced.

Slow smoked pulled pork, house sweet 'n' creamy slaw, carolina sauce.

Slow smoked pulled pork, jalapeno peppadew mac & cheese, og hot sauce drizzle.

Upstate bbq style slow-smoked brisket, sliced to order. No sauce. No veggies. No bs.

Our delicious tender brisket topped with southern style spicy greens, roasted garlic aioli, and garlic parm rub.

Smoked and chopped brisket simmered in our red eye coffee-infused bbq sauce, house dill pickle, super thin onion.

Fresh greens, pulled pork, roasted corn, black beans, pico de gallo, green onion, jalapenos, dry rub sour cream, and a couple chips for crunch factor.

Tender, slow-smoked pork shoulder. Piled high and served on a fresh baked roll. Unsauced

Our pulled pork with carolina bbq, double smoked bacon, dill pickle, swiss sauce

Nickel's classic pulled pork topped with our famous jalapeno peppadew mac and cheese and original hot sauce

Polish style! Schrader farms smoked kielbasa, split and char- broiled, with kraut, house 1000 island, swiss sauce

Our tender, slow-smoked brisket, dipped in au jus and piled onto a white roll. No sauce, no veggies, no bs

(Three b) brisket, bacon, bleu. Our brisket sandwich topped with crumbled bleu cheese and double-smoked bacon

Hot smoked turkey, bacon, fresh greens, tomato, ranch, chiptole honey mustard

Slow smoked pulled pork, house sweet 'n' creamy slaw, carolina sauce

Slow smoked pulled pork, house sweet 'n' creamy slaw, medium buffalo sauce, bleu cheese

Not a "burger," really. Our tender brisket topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, and cheese sauce

A classic nickel's presentation. Split charbroiled kielbasa, pulled pork, and bacon

Feeds a small army of at least 2-it's every- thing! Pulled pork, brisket, kielbasa, smoked turkey, 1/4 chicken, 1/4 rack, 5 wings, 3 pig wings. 2 sides and cornbread

Shout out to our friend's in the roc (nickel's version of rochester's garbage plate). Tots and mac salad, topped with the meat of your choice and smothered with chili, cheddar, and onions. Bread on the side. A big, glorious mess (only served together)

Rubbed and slow smoked - these are big, meaty st. Louis spare ribs

1/2 chicken. Marinated for 24 hours in nickel's chicken sauce, slow smoked, and finished on the char- broiler. We recommend plenty of chicken sauce to dip and drench. With 2 sides and cornbread

Best of both worlds

Tequila, marigold, kaffir, lime, agave, aromatic orange bitters

Bourbon, maple syrup, hickory smoke, aromatic orange bitters

Gin, rose petals, citra hops, grapefruit, lemon, cane sugar

Rum, hibiscus, orange, chipotle, lime

(Flx)

(Flx)

(Flx)

(Flx)

(Za)

(Ar)

(Flx)

(Ca) bottle

Smoked chicken wings, choice of sauce. Includes 2 sides and cornbread.

Have the best of both worlds. all include 2 sides and cornbread.

Our version of the "garbage plate." Tots and mac salad, choice of meat, chili, cheese, and red onion. With bread.

Simply the world's best chicken wing. 10 per order. With carrots, celery, bleu cheese.

We start with big, meaty st. Louis cut ribs, smoke them for 3-4 hours, then crisp them up in the fryer. Tossed with sauce or rub of your choice (above).

Thick-cut dill chunks, beer battered and fried. With house bleu cheese to dip.

Big, hand-cut onion rings, zesty house-made scratch beer batter. House ranch.

Crispy tots with melted cheddar, bacon, green onion, dry rub sour cream, and ranch. Like a loaded potato.

Crispy tots tossed with ranch rub, topped with melty cheddar, bacon, and smoked chicken. With chipotle honey mustard and ranch.

Tots or nachos. Topped with chopped brisket, cheddar cheese sauce, pico de gallo, garlic parm rub, and jalapeno.

Tots or nachos. Topped with chopped brisket, cheddar cheese sauce, pico de gallo, garlic parm rub, and jalapeno.

House-fried tortilla chips topped with our classic pulled pork, jalapeno peppadew cheese sauce, pico de gallo, dry rub sour cream, jalapenos, and our original hot sauce.